Chief Judge Carla E. Craig

All Written Opinions (published and non-published since April 2005)

Show recent opinions first

In Re: Rey v. Laureda et al      Date Filed: 04/27/2005
Case number: 1-04-01416-cec     205301_15_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision for External Web Page Granting motion for summary judgment for the plaintiff(RE: related document(s)[8] Motion for Summary Judgment, filed by Plaintiff Jose A Rey). Signed on 4/27/2005

In Re: Weinstock et al v. Handler et al      Date Filed: 05/17/2005
Case number: 1-04-01174-cec     194669_42_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order Granting Motion for Reconsideration and Vacating the Judgment entered on 3/18/2005 to the extent set forth herein(RE: related document(s)[39] Motion to Reconsider, filed by Plaintiff Israel Weinstock, [38] Order Dismissing Case, ). Signed on 5/17/2005

In Re: Michele Bruno      Date Filed: 07/11/2005
Case number: 1-03-26651-cec     186907_39_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Application for Compensation for Personal Injury Counsel, Jeffrey S Lisabeth (Lisabeth Firm). BG&S's (Breadbar, Garfield and Schmelkin) objection to the payment of the full contingent fee to the Lisabeth Firm is overruled. Trustee is directed to settle an order and judgment consistant with the forgoing and award fees and expenses to the Lisabeth Firm (related document(s)[16]). Signed on 7/11/2005

In Re: American Safety Indemnity Company et al v. Vanderveer Estates Holding, LLC et al      Date Filed: 07/20/2005
Case number: 1-04-01202-cec     196311_32_opinion.pdf
Decision Memorandum Granting the Committee's Application for Summary Judgment and Denying ASIC's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment (related document(s)[13] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by the Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors,[17] Cross-Motion to Direct Response to Subpoenas, to Extend Time for Discovery, for Summary Judgment filed by Plaintiff American Safety Indemnity Company). Signed on 7/20/2005. The Committee is directed to settle an order and a judgment consistent with the foregoing. Certificate of Mailing attached.

In Re: Althea Wright      Date Filed: 08/05/2005
Case number: 1-04-18487-cec     201087_18_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Motion finding Sharinn and Lipshie willfully violated the Automatic Stay. The Court will award fees and expenses to Ms Wright subject to its review of the affidavit which this Court has ordered the Juntikka firm to submit. (Related document #5) Signed on 8/5/2005

In Re: Eronie Henry      Date Filed: 08/05/2005
Case number: 1-04-18738-cec     201469_18_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Motion finding Sharin and Lipshie willfully violated the automatic Stay. The Court will award fees and expenses to Ms. Henry subject to its review of the affidavit which this Court has ordered the Juntikka firm to submit (related document(s)[6] Generic Motion, filed by Debtor Eronie Henry). Signed on 8/5/2005

In Re: Yvonne Parry      Date Filed: 08/05/2005
Case number: 1-04-15725-cec     196960_18_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Motion Seeking Actual Damages and Attorneys' Fees and Punitive Damages From Sharinn & Lipshie, PC, Attorneys for the Judgment Creditor Acting on Behalf of Asset Acceptance LLC for Willful Violations of the Automatic Stay. Designated by Judge as Written Opinion. (RE: related document(s)[6] Generic Motion, filed by Debtor Yvonne Parry). Signed on 8/5/2005

In Re: New World Restaurant Group, Inc v. Abramov et al      Date Filed: 08/31/2005
Case number: 1-03-01688-cec     186934_19_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Denying the discharge of Boris Abramov and Nina Abramov (RE: related document(s)[1] Complaint filed by Counter-Defendant New World Restaurant Group, Inc, Plaintiff New World Restaurant Group, Inc). Plaintiff is directed to settle a separate order and judgment consistent with the foregoing. Signed on 8/31/2005

In Re: Yash Raj Films USA Inc et al v. Ahmed      Date Filed: 10/06/2005
Case number: 1-03-01648-cec     184671_11_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Motion for Summary Judgment and the debt owed to the plaintiffs is nondischargeable (RE: related document(s)[6] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Plaintiff Yash Raj Films USA Inc). Signed on 10/6/2005

In Re: 698 Flushing Realty Corp.      Date Filed: 12/07/2005
Case number: 1-05-19195-cec     230075_36_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision for External Web Page Granting the Dismissal of this Case (RE: related document(s)[30] Motion for Sanctions, filed by Creditor Torianne Thompson, [14] Motion to Dismiss Case, Motion for Relief From Stay, filed by Creditor Torianne Thompson). Signed on 12/7/2005

In Re: Nisselson, as Chapter 7 Co-Trustee of Monahan Ford v. Ford Motor Company et al      Date Filed: 03/20/2006
Case number: 1-04-01500-cec     210627_98_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision (related document(s)[39] Motion to Dismiss/Withdraw Claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, 16, 17, 19, 20 & 33 against Ford Motor Credit Company; [40] Motion to Dismiss/Withdraw Amended Complaint; [48] Motion to Dismiss Claims 1, 6, 7, 9, 19 & 27 of the Amended Complaint). Trustee is directed to settle an appropriate order. Signed on 3/20/2006.

In Re: Admiral Insurance Company v. Grace Industries Inc      Date Filed: 03/27/2006
Case number: 1-05-01084-cec     220567_17_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order for Summary Judgment is denied for Admiral's motion and granted for Grace's motion. Grace is directed to settle an appropriate order. (RE: related document(s)[6] Motion for Summary Judgment, , filed by Defendant Grace Industries Inc). Signed on 3/27/2006

In Re: The Brooklyn Hospital Center      Date Filed: 05/04/2006
Case number: 1-05-26990-cec     241243_269_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Debtors' Motion to Approve the Proposed Key Employee Retention Plan (related document(s)[224] Motion to Authorize and Approve the Debtors' Key Employee Retention Plan filed by Debtor The Brooklyn Hospital Center). The Debtors are directed to settle an order consistent with this decision. Signed on 5/4/2006 (pgm, ) Corrected attachment added on 5/11/2006

In Re: Pergament v. Reisner      Date Filed: 11/21/2006
Case number: 1-06-01256-cec     256666_38_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order Denying Motion for Summary Judgment, except to the limited extent set forth herein. A separate order will be issue (RE: related document(s)[11] Motion for Summary Judgment, , filed by Defendant Muriel Reisner). Signed on 11/21/2006

In Re: PT 1 Communications Inc      Date Filed: 12/07/2006
Case number: 1-01-12655-cec     27559_1004_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision That the IRS's Proof of Claim, to the Extent That it Relates to the 2002 Tax Year, is Expunged. A Separate Order is Being Entered Herewith. (RE: related document(s)[977] Motion for Summary Judgment Expunging the Proof of Claim of the IRS #231, filed by Liquidator Edward P. Bond, Creditor Liquidating Trustee of the Liquidating Trust U/A/W PT-1 Communications, Inc.). Signed on 12/7/2006 (aac, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 2/28/2007 (aac, ). Additional attachment(s) added on 5/15/2007

In Re: PT 1 Communications Inc      Date Filed: 03/26/2007
Case number: 1-01-12655-cec     27559_1023_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order Granting the Trustee's Motion for Summary Judgment Seeking to Expunge the IRS's Request for Administrative Expense Payments for Penalties for Debtor's Failure to Timely Pay Taxes and to Pay Estimated Taxes. Denying Trustee's Motion for Summary Judgment on his Counterclaims Without Prejudice to Renewal Upon a More Complete Record. (RE: related document(s)[977] Generic Motion, filed by Consolidated Debtor PT 1 Long Distance Inc, Consolidated Debtor PT 1Technologies Inc, Liquidator Edward P. Bond, Creditor Liquidating Trustee of the Liquidating Trust U/A/W PT-1 Communications, Inc.). Signed on 3/26/2007 (aac, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 9/17/2008

In Re: Official Committee Of Unsecured Creditors Of Norst v. Lattman et al      Date Filed: 03/30/2007
Case number: 1-06-01279-cec     257127_17_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Denying Defendants' Motion to Dismiss the Complaint designated by Judge as Written Opinon (RE: related document(s) [9] Motion to Dismiss Adversary Proceeding, filed by Defendant Norman Lattman, Defendant Stanley Lattman, Defendant Lattman Irrevocable Family Trust, Defendant Stanley & Ellen Lattman Trust, Defendant Jessica Lattman Trust). Signed on 3/30/2007

In Re: Doyaga v. Roth et al      Date Filed: 09/28/2007
Case number: 1-02-01303-cec     142573_73_opinion.pdf
Decision Granting the Motion to Approve Settlements by and Between Defendants Samuel Roth, Agnes Roth, Morris Roth and Hanshe Leibowitz and the Trustee. (RE: related document(s)[67] Motion to Compromise Controversy, filed by Plaintiff David J Doyaga). Signed on 9/28/2007 (evt, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 9/17/2008

In Re: Russell v. Chase Bank USA, NA      Date Filed: 12/06/2007
Case number: 1-06-01502-cec     262547_17_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order that Chase's motion to dismiss the defamation claim is granted, and Chase's motion to dismiss Russell's claim for violation of the discharge injunction under section 524(a)(2) is denied. (Related document(s)[6] Motion to Dismiss Case, filed by Defendant Chase Bank USA, NA). Signed on 12/6/2007

In Re: Cole v. Household Financial et al      Date Filed: 02/07/2008
Case number: 1-07-01619-cec     277155_6_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision. The debtor's Motion to Vacate the Dismissal Order in the 2000 case is denied and the adversary proceeding filed on December 21, 2007, is dismissed. Separate orders will issue herewith. (RE: [1] Complaint filed by Plaintiff Sonia Cole). Signed on 2/7/2008 (dkc, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 5/20/2008

In Re: Marco Antonio Chavez      Date Filed: 02/11/2008
Case number: 1-06-41449-cec     257126_49_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Motion to Estimate Proof of Claim No 6 filed by Ms Duncan in the amount of $ 28,916.04.(RE: related document(s)[29] Motion to Object/Reclassify/Reduce/Expunge Claims, filed by Debtor Marco Antonio Chavez). Signed on 2/11/2008

In Re: Sharon M Combes      Date Filed: 02/19/2008
Case number: 1-06-44788-cec     263218_30_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision DENYING Trustee's Motion in its entirety (RE: related document(s)[9] Motion to Object to Debtor's Claim of Exemptions, filed by Trustee Richard J. McCord). Signed on 2/19/2008

In Re: Jeffrey H Shankman      Date Filed: 02/27/2008
Case number: 1-07-40001-cec     263811_64_opinion.pdf
Decision allowing the debtor to convert the case and giving him the opportunity to propose a plan (in which he might sell the apartment) does not adversely effect the efficient administration of the estate in a material way. For the foregoing reasons, the debtor's Chapter 13 case is dismissed and his request to convert his Chapter 7 case to one under Chapter 13 is granted. A separate order will issue herewith. Signed on 2/27/2008

In Re: Jeffrey Shankman      Date Filed: 02/27/2008
Case number: 1-07-46258-cec     275661_31_opinion.pdf
Decision DISMISSING the debtor's Chapter 13 case and the debtor's request to convert his Chapter 7 case (07-40001) to one under Chapter 13 is GRANTED. The debtor is barred from filing a Chapter 13 case while his Chapter 7 case is pending (RE: related document(s)[13] Motion to Dismiss Case filed by Trustee Michael J. Macco, [14] Motion to Dismiss Case, Motion for Relief From Stay filed by Creditor Clearview Gardens Sixth Corporation). Signed on 2/27/2008

In Re: M. Fine Lumber Co., Inc.      Date Filed: 03/12/2008
Case number: 1-07-43529-cec     270342_115_opinion.pdf
Decision (RE: related document(s)[94] Motion to Assume/Reject Lease or Executory Contract filed by Debtor M. Fine Lumber Co., Inc) Granted, conditioned upon the Debtor paying the following amounts to the Landlord, within ten days after the entry of this Court's order authorizing assumption of the Lease: 1) $24,961.74, representing pre-petition rental arrears; 2) $50,000, as an additional security deposit; and 3) $7,000 on account of attorneys' fee due under the Lease. The latter amount is to be held by the Landlord's counsel pending determination of the amount of attorneys' fees owed, which will be set down for a hearing. Signed on 3/12/2008 (tml) Correct attachment(s) added on 3/13/2008 (djr, ). Modified on 3/13/2008

In Re: Severius Raggie      Date Filed: 07/01/2008
Case number: 1-06-40031-cec     254242_26_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order Granting Mr. Raggie's motion to amend Schedule B and his Statement of Financial Affairs. (RE: related document(s)[19] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Severius Raggie). Signed on 7/1/2008

In Re: McCord v. Jaspan Schlesinger Hoffman LLP      Date Filed: 07/02/2008
Case number: 1-04-01496-cec     210572_69_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision - The Trustee's motion for partial summary judgment is granted in part and denied in part, and the Jaspan Firm's cross-motion for summary judgment is denied(RE: related document(s)[50] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Defendant Jaspan Schlesinger Hoffman LLP, [46] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Plaintiff Richard J McCord). Signed on 7/2/2008

In Re: Selena J Morra      Date Filed: 09/05/2008
Case number: 8-04-81042-cec      191751_55_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order For the foregoing reasons, the Trustee's motion to disallow the debtor's exemption of the 401(k) plan is denied. A separate order will issue.(RE: related document(s)[25] Motion to Object/Reclassify/Reduce/Expunge Claims,filed by Trustee Robert L. Pryor). Signed on 9/5/2008

In Re: Stuart Stein      Date Filed: 09/17/2008
Case number: 1-99-13154-cec     116250_27_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting Debtor's Motion to Reopen case; a separate order will issue.(RE: related document(s)[11] Motion to Reopen Chapter 7 Case filed by Debtor Stuart Stein). Signed on 9/17/2008

In Re: Sonia Maria Cole      Date Filed: 02/07/2008
Case number: 1-00-20181-cec      11518_38_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order. The debtor's Motion to Vacate the Dismissal Order in the 2000 case is denied and the adversary proceeding filed on December 21, 2007, is dismissed. Separate orders will issue herewith. Signed on 2/7/2008 (dkc, ) Additional attachment(s) added on 9/17/2008

In Re: Rosen v. Breitner & Hoffman, P.C.      Date Filed: 09/29/2008
Case number: 1-07-01600-cec      275993_18_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order that the Breitner's motion for summary judgment in the Debtor Action and its motion to dismiss the Trustee Action are denied. A separate order will issue.. Signed on 9/29/2008

In Re: Flushing Hospital Medical Center v. Breitner & Hoffman, P.C.      Date Filed: 09/29/2008
Case number: 1-07-01618-cec      277122_19_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision DENYING Breitner's motion for summary judgment in the Debtor Action and Breitner's motion to dismiss the Trustee's Action (RE: related document(s)[7] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Defendant Breitner & Hoffman, P.C.) Signed on 9/29/2008

In Re: Ulysses T Moulterie      Date Filed: 12/23/2008
Case number: 1-06-45102-cec      263758_54_opinion.pdf
Decision denying the Trustee's motion to disallow the Debtor's homestead exemption in the property. A separate order will issue.(RE: related document(s)[27] Motion to Object to Debtor's Claim of Exemptions filed by Trustee Robert J Musso). Signed on 12/23/2008 (jrw) Additional attachment(s) added on 12/23/2008

In Re: Physicians' Reciprocal Insurers v. The Brunswick Hospital Center, Inc. et al      Date Filed: 02/06/2009
Case number: 1-08-01070-cec      281837_24_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Granting PRI's Motion for Summary Judgment, Denying Ms. Nester's Cross Motion for Summary Judgment and Brunswick's request for Determination. (RE: related document(s)[6] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Counter-Defendant Physicians' Reciprocal Insurers, Plaintiff Physicians' Reciprocal Insurers, [9] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Defendant Cynthia Nester). Signed on 2/6/2009

In Re: Plaza Equities LLC et al v. Pauker as Trustee et al      Date Filed: 02/26/2009
Case number: 8-07-08253-cec      273890_43_opinion.pdf
Decision(RE: related document(s)[39] Motion to Authorize/Direct filed by Counter-Claimant David Pauker as Trustee, Defendant David Pauker as Trustee). Settlement Agreement Between the Trustee and the Kiley Parties is Approved. A Separate Order Will Issue Herewith. Signed on 2/26/2009

In Re: Josph M Bruckman      Date Filed: 03/17/2009
Case number: 1-07-43930-cec      271170_70_opinion.pdf
Decision. The Debtor's Motion to Dismiss is Denied. A separate Order will issue herewith. (RE: related document(s)[45] Motion to Dismiss Case filed by Debtor Josph M Bruckman). Signed on 3/17/2009

In Re: PT 1 Communications Inc      Date Filed: 03/31/2009
Case number: 1-01-12655-cec      27559_1135_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order. The Trustee's motion for Summary Judgment is granted to the extent that the IRS's administrative expense payment request for Short Period is disallowed, the IRS is directed to accept PT-1's Stub Period tax return, and the Trustee is awarded the 1998 Tax Refund. The Trustee's motion for Summary Judgment on his counterclaim for the 2001 Tax Refund is denied, and this issue is set down for an evidentiary hearing. A separate order shall issue herewith(RE: related document(s)[1032]). Signed on 3/31/2009

In Re: Yesh Diamonds Inc., v. Yashaya      Date Filed: 03/31/2009
Case number: 1-08-01100-cec      283058_14_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order. The Debtor's Motion is granted and this Adversary Proceeding is dismissed with prejudice. A separate order will issue (RE: related document(s)[7] Motion to Dismiss Adversary Proceeding). Signed on 3/31/2009

In Re: Larry Bresnick      Date Filed: 06/23/2009
Case number: 1-07-41580-cec      266757_243_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision Denying Lawrence Morrison's Application for Compensation for Work Performed After the Date of the Appointment of the Trustee. (RE: related document(s)[228] Application for Compensation filed by Debtor Larry Bresnick). Signed on 6/23/2009

In Re: Benjumen v. City College of New York/City University of New Yo      Date Filed: 07/20/2009
Case number: 1-07-01456-cec      271941_59_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order (RE: related document(s) [16], [18], [21] Motion for Summary Judgment). Signed on 7/20/2009

In Re: Pryor v. Morra      Date Filed: 07/21/2009
Case number: 8-06-08099-cec      255223_28_opinion.pdf
Decision (RE: [20] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Plaintiff Robert L Pryor, [23] Cross-Motion filed by Defendant Selena J Morra). The Trustee's motion for summary judgment and the Debtor's motion for summary judgment are denied, and the issue of the Debtor's good faith in making the Contributions will be set down for a hearing. A separate order will issue. Signed on 7/21/2009

In Re: Bettie Jean Sanders      Date Filed: 07/24/2009
Case number: 1-07-45689-cec      274621_35_opinion.pdf
Decision(RE: related document(s)[32] Reconsideration and Motion for a Permanent Injunction and Restraining Order filed by Filed by Wilfred A Callendar on behalf of Bettie Jean Sanders. For the foregoing reasons, all of the Debtor's Motions are denied, and RSL's Motion for the Relief From the Automatic Stay with prejudice for a period of one year is granted. A separate order will be issued. Signed on 7/24/2009

In Re: Bettie Jean Sanders      Date Filed: 07/24/2009
Case number: 1-08-47128-cec      291016_54_opinion.pdf
Decision and Order Denying all of the Debtor's motions [50] and Granting RSL's Motion for relief from the automatic stay with prejudice for a period of one year (related document(s)[10]). See document# 53 for separate order. Signed on 7/24/2009

In Re: PT 1 Communications Inc      Date Filed: 08/28/2009
Case number: 1-01-12655-cec      27559_1164_opinion.pdf
Decision. For the forgoing reasons, USAC's motion for relief from the Claim Order is Denied. A separate order will issue (RE: related document(s)[341] Motion to Object/Reclassify/Reduce/Expunge Claims, [353] Order on Motion to Object/Reclassify/Reduce/Expunge Claims, [663] Motion to Reconsider , [749] Order on Motion To Reconsider, [1024] Order District Court re: Appeal). Signed on 8/28/2009 (Attachments: # (1) Mailing Certificate)

In Re: E. Armata, Inc. et al v. Parra      Date Filed: 09/11/2009
Case number: 1-08-01439-cec      294000_9_opinion.pdf
Decision(RE: related document(s)[4] Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Plaintiff E. Armata, Inc., Plaintiff A&J Produce Corp.). The Plaintiffs motion for summary judgment is granted in part, to the extent that the Court finds that the Defendant acted in a fiduciary capacity under §523(a)(4), and denied in part, to the extent that an issue of material fact exists whether theDefendant committed a defalcation. A separate order shall issue herewith. Signed on 9/11/2009

In Re: Emmanuel Wassah      Date Filed: 09/17/2009
Case number: 1-08-47870-cec      292645_40_opinion.pdf
Decision denying the motions of Mr. Wassah and Mr. Matthews for relief from the orders dismissing their respective bankruptcy cases. A separate order will issue (related document(s)[26] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah, [28] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah, [29] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah). Signed on 9/17/2009

In Re: Terrence O Matthews      Date Filed: 09/17/2009
Case number: 1-08-45175-cec      287290_32_opinion.pdf
Decision denying the motions of Mr. Wassah and Mr. Matthews for relief from the orders dismissing their respective bankruptcy cases. A separate order will issue (related document(s)[26] Motion to Waive Filing Fee filed by Debtor Terrence O Matthews, Motion to Reopen Chapter 13 Case, [27] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Terrence O Matthews, [28] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Terrence O Matthews). Signed on 9/17/2009

In Re: Emmanuel Wassah      Date Filed: 09/17/2009
Case number: 1-08-45174-cec      287289_44_opinion.pdf
Decision denying the motions of Mr. Wassah and Mr. Matthews for relief from the orders dismissing their respective bankruptcy cases. A separate order will issue (related document(s)[33] Motion to Reinstate Case filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah, Motion to Vacate, [34] Motion to Continue/Reschedule Hearing filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah, [36] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah, [37] Motion to Continue/Reschedule Hearing filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah, [43] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Emmanuel Wassah). Signed on 9/17/2009

In Re: Terrence O Matthews      Date Filed: 09/17/2009
Case number: 1-08-47869-cec      292644_34_opinion.pdf
Decision denying the motions of Mr. Wassah and Mr. Matthews for relief from the orders dismissing their respective bankruptcy cases. A separate order will issue (related document(s)[24] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Terrence O Matthews, [25] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Terrence O Matthews, [26] Motion to Reconsider filed by Debtor Terrence O Matthews). Signed on 9/17/2009

In Re: Grace Industries, Inc. v. New York State Department of Transportation et al      Date Filed: 09/23/2009
Case number: 1-07-01464-cec      272067_69_opinion.pdf
Opinion/Decision, the Agreement by and between Plaintiff and Defendant is not an enforceable contract and Grace's Motion pursuant to Rule 52(c) is granted. (RE: related document(s)[38] Motion to Authorize/Direct filed by Counter-Claimant Grace Industries, Inc., Counter-Defendant Grace Industries, Inc., Plaintiff Grace Industries, Inc., [46] Memorandum of Law in Support filed by Counter-Claimant Grace Industries, Inc., Counter-Defendant Grace Industries, Inc., Plaintiff Grace Industries, Inc.). Signed on 9/23/2009

In Re: Isack Rosenberg      Date Filed: 11/18/2009
Case number: 1-09-46326-cec      307257_117_opinion.pdf
Decision (RE: related document(s)[100] Motion to Compromise Controversy filed by Debtor Isack Rosenberg). The Settlement Agreement is approved. A separate Order is being entered herewith. Signed on 11/18/2009